osprey_archer: (books)
This month in writing, I accomplished many small things!

1. Wrote [personal profile] kore’s Natasha/Yelena story, Tea for Two.

2. Made covers & wrote descriptions for standalone releases of my two magical pet short stories, “The Mating Call of the Teleporting Warbler” and “Care and Feeding.”

3. Also wrote and collected short descriptions of all my books so that in the future when I need to put together back matter I can just copy and paste from a single document. Why did I not do this years ago? A mystery.

4. Released The Mating Call of the Teleporting Warbler as a standalone short story. This was worth doing because I’d already written the story and I knocked together the cover very cheaply, but the sales figures suggest that writing short stories specifically for release on Amazon would not be profitable.

Having said that, this story is f/f, which generally has pretty low sales figures. The picture might look different with a different genre.

5. In the interest of exploring this question, I expanded “Care and Feeding,” from the m/m magical pet anthology. It now ends with a sex scene instead of “If I make this any longer I’m going to have to write a sex scene, so the story is ending… NOW.” Planning to release this in May, perhaps.

6. I am dragging sloooowly forward on the novelette about two fangirls who hit it off in real life… only to realize they are fandom nemeses! Just hit 15,000 words, have written absolutely everything except the sex scene, so I guess I gotta bite the bullet and write that.

Thinking about calling the story Enemies to Lovers, although the title might be too generic? The working title is “Fangirl Foeyay,” but I don’t think people use the word foeyay anymore. It may not even have been in common use when I wrote the first three-quarters of a draft back in 2016. (I pondered whether I should update the fandom references, but that would require major surgery, and it would 10,000 times easier to slide in a mention that the story takes place in December 2015.)

***

My goals for April is to finish a draft of Enemies to Lovers, polish “Care and Feeding,” and write [personal profile] evelyn_b’s She-Ra fic (Scorpia + Kyle = unexpected friendship). (Still doing fics for ACLU donations of $25+ if anyone is interested! Should probably make a new post about this.)

I would also like to decide on my next project. I started some projects in 2020 that I hope to complete eventually, but right there’s a lot of accumulated frustration bound up in them, so I’ve set them aside to give that time to dissipate.

However, when I dug up Enemies to Lovers, I found two older possibilities in my archives.

1. There’s a partially complete m/m “contemporary but everyone knows about vampires and magic generally so it’s not exactly our world” story. Soon after moving to the big city, Chris falls in with charming, obnoxious, mysterious Josh… whose secret turns out to be NOT that he is a cheating bastard, but that he is a vampire’s blood thrall. (Yes, there is emphatically a scene where the vampire drinks just a little too much blood and Josh faints from blood loss).

The main problem with this one - the reason why I abandoned it in the first place, lo these many years ago - is that I couldn’t figure out workable answers to a couple of basic questions. How did Josh end up in thralldom? The best answer I came up with was “Josh killed another vampire, and thralldom is his legal punishment,” but if that’s the case, how can Josh escape? It’s not really a happy ending if Josh is still in thrall to the vampire who might any day “accidentally” drink so much blood that he dies.

2. The other option is to take Iced Coffee Dreams off Amazon, rewrite it as f/f, and release it for Kalikoi. When I released it under the Jennifer Montgomery pen name it sold ten copies (actually, it may have been less than ten…) and it would be nice to actually make some money off it.
osprey_archer: (Winter Soldier)
Oh hey! I wrote a fic! [personal profile] kore took me up on my fics in return for charity donations offer, which remains open, btw, in case anyone wants a fic For Great Justice.

This one is a Natasha fic. I have been vaguely kicking around this idea for ages (which of Natasha's old contacts did she get that file from?) and I'm delighted to have written it before the Black Widow movie comes out and presumably josses all of my thoughts on the matter.

Fic: Tea for Two
Fandom: MCU (post-Captain America: The Winter Soldier, drawing on the Black Widow trailer for Yelena characterization)
Rating: General audiences
Warnings: None
Relationships: Natasha Romanov/Yelena Belova
Characters: Natasha Romanov, Yelena Belova, mentions of Steve Rogers & Bucky Barnes
Summary: After the helicarriers fall, Natasha goes to an old friend to bargain for the Winter Soldier's file. Yelena is delighted to have this chance to gloat.
osprey_archer: (writing)
I have finished a draft of David and Robert. I’ve said this perhaps four times at this point, but this time it really seems to be sticking, so I’m going to have to find something else to write. This is unfortunate, because everything else I’ve tried to write during this pandemic feels dull and lifeless and crumbles in my hands around the 10,000 word mark.

I wish I could figure out what made it possible for me to write David and Robert because then maybe I could copy that quality into another story, which I would then also be able to write. Instead I am adrift, like a skiff on high seas, and the world is deprived of the further outpourings of my genius, etc. etc.

Also, although the Honeytrap tail has been doing really well for me (with the Valentine’s sale I’ll be breaking $600 for February), that’s not going to continue indefinitely. How can I amass money for JapanTrip2022 if I can’t write anything?

Uggggh.

Anyway, my goal for March is to finally write that Natasha fic I promised [personal profile] kore. (Yesterday I rewatched Winter Soldier as Research. Remember when Marvel movies actually gave the character moments time to breathe?) Once I’ve finished that, I’ll go from there.
osprey_archer: (writing)
Today I have stories coming out in not one but TWO anthologies! They are a matched set, both on the theme of “magical pets,” one m/m and one f/f: His Magical Pet and Her Magical Pet. The proceeds for both are donated to OutRight Action International, which fights for the rights of LGBTQIA people worldwide.

I haven’t had the opportunity to read the His Magical Pet stories yet (except for my own story, of course, which is about two friends who pined over each other in high school, then reunited after years apart, and finally admit that they love each other with the help of the winged bichon frise that they rescued years ago) but I had the pleasure of proofreading Her Magical Pet so I have read all of those. A few of my favorites include:

“Beach Dirt on Bare Feet,” which is about a selkie! and a psychic! who connect with the help of the psychic’s dolphin friend!!! The psychic introduces the selkie to the pleasures of ice cream and it is adorable.

“As if the Sun Came to Shine,” which features a half-troll on the run from Fairyland and the changeling who has slowly gained her trust. I loved the prose and the worldbuilding in this one. Would love to see a longer story set in this world.

I also loved the prose and the worldbuilding in “How to Get a Girlfriend (When You’re a Terrifying Monster),” which features a human researcher coming through a portal into the Endless Dimension, which is… well, I’d better just quote the story:

“In the constantly changing void of the Endless Dimension, there is no such thing as people. There is only one person—or perhaps ‘being’ would be a better word. The constant, hungering entity that both is and fills the entire dimension: the Endless itself. Fragments of the Endless sometimes fracture off, spattering free like bubbles in a galactic pot of porridge, but they are quickly absorbed again, and anything they learned or thought or felt while they were separated is gobbled back up into the hungering one-ness.

Except for one.”

That one entity who broke off from the Endless is, of course, our other heroine. She is so fascinated by the researcher that she attempts to fashion herself a similar body, except it’s a bit awkward remembering to have arms instead of tentacles, and also that it’s necessary to have bones and so forth. Delightful. Probably my favorite story in the collection.

And of course I think that my own story, “The Mating Call of the Teleporting Warbler,” is delightful, although probably you shouldn’t trust the author on this sort of thing. It’s an epistolary story in which a winged cat carries messages between an established f/f couple, one of whom is on a summer fieldwork project studying the titular teleporting warblers. They reminisce about how they first got together.
osprey_archer: (writing)
Writing goals for June, in public

- revise [personal profile] ancientreader's fic for charity (current title: "Things We Lost in the Fire")
- revise the Goblin Market retelling (current title: "Goblin Woods") and send it to Carnation Books
- write ~20,000 words on the silent film book (current title: "A Coracle of Stars," but I literally just started writing is so we'll see if that sticks.
- come up with a solid idea (plot/characters) for an m/m book. It's probably a little too on the nose if I write one about a sulky Soviet assassin, isn't it?
osprey_archer: (writing)
I’m galloping toward the end of Ashlin & Olivia - finally found a good picture for the cover! Very curious to see if the paperback sells more if it comes out concurrently with the ebook. But the paperback will be coming out either way, because I’m selling books at Pride this year. My mother thinks I should also try to reach out to local bookstores. Is that a thing self-pubbed authors do?

But if I did reach out to bookstores, that would be an opportunity to do something with the paperback version of The English Breakfast Affair (I put it together as a Mother’s Day present because it’s my mother’s favorite of my books), which is unsuitable for Pride but might find an audience at bookstores. Hmm.

But anyway! I’m also getting my ducks in a row for my next writing projects. First, I have another charity fic to write (offer still open, incidentally, probably as long as Trump is president). This one takes place sometime after the end of Reciprocity and will feature, among other charms, this exchange:

Bucky: “Do you know what was wrong with the orphanage stories, Steve? They weren’t grim enough.”

Steve: “....No. I never thought that was what was wrong with the orphanage stories.”

Then I need to do revisions on my rough draft of a modern-day retelling of “Goblin Market” set at a university.

After that! I have three potential ideas to choose from!

1. In the waning days of World War I, a princess (serving in disguise as a fighter pilot) rushes back to her tiny homeland to rescue her brother, the crown prince, from the Communist revolutionaries who want to behead him...who just happen to be led by the princess’s best friend from Swiss finishing school.

Pros: THE DRAMA.

Cons: The research. It’s not so much the World War I that concerns me as the German background.

2. A Little Red Riding Hood retelling that begins in tsarist Russia and ends in the theaters of Paris, where our heroine has been performing as Little Red Riding Hood with her wolf friend, who is actually a student revolutionary transformed into a wolf by her fellow anarchists once she tried to defect from their plan to topple the tsar by making a deal with the devil.

Pros: THE DRAMA.

Cons: I don’t know how to end this one. How can a girl and a wolf can defeat half a dozen Satanic anarchists? Also, the fact that one of the heroines spends most of the book as a wolf strikes me as an insuperable barrier to romance.

3. A silent film actress-turned-director recruits an old friend/ex-lover to make car chase movie together during the waning days of independent silent film production.

Pros: This one is slightly less DRAMA but it still has lots of exciting possibilities. The girls will be doing their own stunts and you know someone’s going to get hurt and there will be h/c POSSIBILITIES.

Cons: This one might be all pro, actually. I’ve already lined up some more books to read about women behind the camera in silent film.

4. I would also like to write another m/m story, but I have no specific ideas for this one, only a stew of vague “this would be cool to use in a story someday” ideas. Springtime! A glass-bottomed chain ferry! (I wanted to use that one in Ashlin and Olivia but I just couldn’t make it fit.) Maybe I should go somewhere cool just to work it into a story.
osprey_archer: (writing)
I’ve finally caught up on the fics-for-ACLU donations that I’ve promised… just in time for everything to become even more terrible than usual yet again. 

So. It’s Fics to Fight Family Separation time. (I don’t have the chops to put together a fandom auction, but… have we considered a fandom auction? Is there a fandom auction happening and I just haven’t seen it?) Donate $20+ to either the ACLU or one of the organizations listed in this Slate article, send me the receipt, & I’ll write you a fic. 

(Or perhaps an essay, or a movie review, if either of those happen to strike your fancy. I am flexible. Let's raise some money.)

There's a comprehensive list of fandoms I've written in before here on AO3; I'd be happy to write for most book or movie fandoms, but it's been ages since I've watched any of the TV shows on the list, so those are probably not a great idea. (Fic for TV shows has never been my strong suit anyway.) If there's a book or movie you know I've read/seen and you'd like fic for that, let's talk.

I will also consider origfic prompts if you have a yen for that, although I think it’s harder to make origfic satisfying at short length. But we’ll see! If I end up running really wild with something I can always sell it on Kindle.
osprey_archer: (writing)
I finished reading The Three Musketeers a month or two ago and did not post about it because I was Very Upset with some of Dumas’ choices about the ending, in particular about one of the characters he decided to kill, and therefore probably could not have written anything except “KEYBOARD SMASH RAGE WHAT HOW COULD YOU?”

I have calmed down enough to write a fix-it fic, and now I feel much better. It is, of course, a spoiler for the ending (for a book that is 150 years old, but still), so I’m going to put it Behind a spoiler cut )

Weirdly, despite the keyboard smashing rage that the book ending inspired, I now want to search out retellings of the story - rewatch the 1993 Disney version (I got the VHS when I was about 11 and watched it so many times that I broke it), perhaps see the Doug Fairbanks version, maybe watch the recent BBC series? I’ve heard that the BBC series is only VERY LOOSELY based on the book, buuuut the book seems to have been VERY LOOSELY based on history in the first place, so really I think loose adaptations in the name of extra swashbuckling are the most Dumasian thing of all.
osprey_archer: (writing)
[personal profile] evelyn_b won a fic from me in the [community profile] fandomlovespuertorico auction, and one of her prompts was "Vane and Troy's Awkward Adventures."

So I've finally finished that fic! It is not very long, so I will in the long run write another auction fic, but for now - please enjoy the Awkward Adventures.

Onward to the fic! )
osprey_archer: (Default)
Building your army of conquest was the easy part. This week, the Society for Improved Dictatorship will move on to the more delicate side of minion acquisition: how does a dictator fill his inner circle?

Here are the two most important qualities in a minion: they must be good company, and they should make good fall guys. Remember, you’re going to be spending hours every day with these men, so you ought to enjoy their company. This is far more important than their supposed competence at their jobs. That’s what they have assistants for! Your minions’ most important task is keeping you entertained.

Besides, it will make your minions delightfully insecure if they know that their assistants are the ones who are truly doing their work. It will tend to engender jealousy and dislike and nip in the bud any deplorable tendencies toward loyalty to their underlings.

Loyalty, in fact, is one of the qualities that you emphatically do not want in a minion. Real internal loyalty, rather than the showy ass-kissing kind, can be dangerous and unpredictable; you never know what undeserved wretch or stupid cause a truly loyal minion may decide to die for. They should be too terrified of you for their loyalty to ever come into question. They should be willing to throw anyone else under the bus at a moment’s notice, up to and including their wives and children.

There is a charming story about Stalin’s minion Molotov, whose beloved wife was arrested late in Stalin’s reign. He continued to set a place for her at the table when he ate dinner at home, in his bugged house, surrounded by his servants who were Stalin’s spies – but made no actual move to free her. Thus, his seeming display of defiance was actually a slavish display of terrified loyalty: although you have broken my heart, Stalin, I continue to serve you faithfully every day. Strive to instill such terror in your minions.

Machiavelli was a fool when he suggested that it is better to be feared than loved. If fear is strong enough, it creates love.

If you force enough obsequious outpourings, even people who yearn to hate you will find that you are wrapped around their hearts – as Anya von Bremzen’s would-be dissident mother discovered when Stalin died, and she realized that her dream of being an actress had died with him, because in her heart she had always yearned to perform before him.

And she had never even met Stalin! The force of your personality should make this effect even more powerful on your minions. You will be their abusive father and cruel lover (emotionally rather than physically) and they will never be free of you even decades after your death.

Now, as to your minions’ personalities, we suggest that you consult your own tastes. Every dictator is different. Get yourself an obsequious toady if that’s what you want. Do you like the spectacle of cringing cowardice? Treat yourself. We suggest you limit yourself to one or two minions of this variety, because occasionally you will need minions who have some resolution and force of character – but you can certainly have that one or two.

Indeed, a toady or a coward will be very useful to you. They are likely to be quite unpopular not only with their fellow minions, but with the populace at large. This will happen even if you allow no mention of their unpleasant qualities in your official press. Rumors get out. It is impossible to quash them entirely, so be selective. Anything less than flattering about yourself must be quashed, but your minions… well, if you need one of them to take a fall, it helps if there are already some ugly rumors floating about to prepare the populace.

And thus we arrive at the second most important quality in a minion: being a good fall guy. We don’t advise that you should dispose of your minions recklessly, mind. If your inner circle is in a constant state of flux, it makes you look out of control. That will make your populace nervous. They want to know that you are steering the ship of state with a strong and steady hand.

But occasionally, a military defeat, an overly enthusiastic purge, or a misjudged policy will cause such unrest that it must be blamed on someone, and that’s what your minions are for.

A few helpful notes about finding good fall guys. We’ve already mentioned a few personality characteristics to look for: cowards and toadies are generally unpopular and easily destroyed. Boring technocrats fall into much the same category. Do you have a minion who likes to corner people at parties and drone on about agricultural statistics? That’s your man if there’s a famine. No one will weep for him.

People with visible deformities also make good fall guys. Any issue that distorts the face, like goiters or elephantiasis, will prime your populace with distrust. Humans flinch from ugliness. Exploit this base instinct.

However, we recognize that in this one instance you may share this weakness with your populace, and may not wish to look at a minion with a pendulous goiter every day. In that case, ethnic minorities may prove an attractive choice. The populace may warm to them despite their origin, but their ingrained mistrust will remain underneath – and that mistrust will flare swiftly with the aid of a well-prepared newspaper campaign when you need to blame that minion for something.

Also, ethnic minorities and deformed people make excellent employees. They know that you’ve given them an opportunity that they might never have gotten anywhere else, and they will generally be suitably grateful, or at least suitably hard-working.

If you can find a minion who is a deformed ethnic minority and also a sexual deviant of some variety, congratulations! That’s a hat trick. Make him the head of your secret police, wink indulgently at his bizarre sexual habits, and then throw him under the bus when your purges get out of hand.

A note about sexual deviancy: always remember that humans are censorious hypocrites in the end. Any sex that is not marital heterosexual intercourse in the missionary position is potentially deviant if you need it to be. It may be ideal for a minion to have drug-fueled homosexual orgies, but a collection of women’s stockings can take someone down in a pinch.

If you find that you yourself are an ethnic minority or deformed, fear not. Stalin was a pockmarked Georgian with a withered arm, but he nonetheless rose to become the Soviet Union’s unchallenged dictator. You have total control of the media. (And if you don’t, why the hell not?) Force them to present you in a flattering light.

And if you find yourself suffering from any lingering qualms of conscience about betraying your minions like this… Remember, it is their job to support you, and that means sacrificing themselves if it’s in your best interests. They ought to be proud to provide this glorious service to your empire! And you ought to remember that conscience is nothing but a set of chains for lesser mortals. You’re above all that. Nothing moves you but the exigencies of power.
osprey_archer: (writing)
This isn't an auction fic per se, but when I linked to the Fandom Loves Puerto Rico auction [personal profile] asakiyume offered to donate to Puerto Rico relief outside of the auction if I wrote more "How to Be a Better Dictator"...

And, well, who am I to refuse an opportunity to give dictators the benefit of my advice? (And to raise money for a good cause obvs.) It's no longer specifically Hunger Games related (I think I got that out of my system; although I still haven't seen the movies so WHO KNOWS what stupid things President Snow might get up to there?), but general advice for your average dictator-on-the-street.

(This offer is open, btw. If you've got a burning desire for an installment of How to Be a Better Dictator and a spare ten dollars or more for either ConPRmetidos or the ACLU, you know where to find me.)

***

“How can I find good minions?” This harrowing cry echoes through the correspondence of the Society for Improved Dictatorship. In response, we have decided to promulgate a pair of pamphlets about minion recruitment: one dedicated to recruiting common soldiers to fill your legions, and another for the more delicate task of finding high-ranking minions who display the perfect blend of loyalty, initiative, and subservience.

We use the word “recruiting” advisedly, because we at the SfID believe that old-fashioned recruitment is still the best way to fill the ranks of the army. Clone and robot armies are fashionable right now, but ultimately they’re just a fad, and an expensive one at that.

Now, there are a number of problems we could point out with both clone and robot armies. We could note that clones start out as infants, so it will be years before your army will be of any use to you – and in the meantime, you’ll have to pay someone to take care of those baby clones. We could also mention that genetically identical soldiers are also going to have genetically identical susceptibility to diseases – and you just know that your enemies will have their labs working night and day to find the clone blight that will rip through your armies like the potato blight ripped through the Irish potato crop back in the 1840s.

Irish potatoes all sprang from the same two potato plants that had been brought over from the New World years before. They were genetically identical incestuous potato clones. That’s what caused the Irish potato famine.

Moving on to a robot army, we might comment on the vulnerability of an army composed of soldiers who have no free will. Now, doubtless this seems like an advantage to you, but let’s think of the drawbacks. If the robots are centrally controlled, that control system will be all too easy for your enemies to hack. If, on the other hand, you try to give the robots some decision-making ability of their own, you run the risk of stumbling into true self-determination, in which case you’ll lose the total obedience that is the one true advantage that robots have over human soldiers. A robot that can make decisions is a robot that can rebel. This is the insoluble problem of free will.

Besides, metal and petroleum, the two resources you need to build robots, are expensive and nonrenewable. Humans, on the other hand, will reproduce themselves pretty much infinitely if you give them half a chance. The cost analysis here is clear.

In the end, robot and clone armies suffer from the same core conceptual flaw: they are attempts to design improvements on perfection. Humans are already killing machines. You’re not going to design anything better than what you’ve already got.

So why waste money on engineering when your own populace is growing a bumper crop of cannon fodder right outside your door? And at their own expense, too!

Moreover, an army recruited from the populace is a great loyalty enhancer. You have a golden opportunity to indoctrinate every single one of your recruits right down to the ground. Remember, people value group membership more if they have to fight to earn it. Your army training regime should be brutal. Hazing ought to be encouraged.

This effect will work even on unwilling recruits, but it is strongest if people join the army willingly. We realize there is some dictatorial cachet in dragging your weeping recruits from their relative’s loving arms, and of course you should always keep the draft in your back pocket as an option. But we believe it makes a stronger fighting force if at least some of your troops are there by choice.

Does your army offer opportunities for advancement that lower-class children could never find in civilian life? The chances for advancement need not be high to sucker recruits in. Hope springs eternal among the young. They all believe they’ll be the one who makes officer.

At very least, be sure the army’s got a snappy uniform. Rare is the peasant lad who can resist the opportunity to wear a swooshy cape.

But the benefits don’t stop with the recruits! Recruitment enhances regime loyalty not only among the soldiers themselves, but among their home communities! You might think that people might turn against you as their hometown’s finest sons begin to die in your wars, but in fact the effect is often the opposite. Once people have sacrificed their most precious possession to your cause, they strive to justify that loss, which binds them ever more tightly to your regime. It’s called the sunk cost fallacy. Exploit it to the hilt.

We hope this pamphlet has helped you resist the current fashion for clone and robot armies. Remember, you’re the dictator. Don’t let fads dictate to you!
osprey_archer: (writing)
I am participating in a fandom auction to raise money for Puerto Rico, so if you have a yen to buy a fic from me, now is the time! My post is here. Come buy, come buy!
osprey_archer: (writing)
I posted a fic on AO3 before I left for Miami, & then forgot to post a link over here! Although in general I've gotten out of the loop of posting links to my fics here. Must correct this.

Title: Mary, Mary, Quite Contrary
Fandom: Agents of SHIELD/MCU
Pairings: a bit of Bucky/Daisy but not much
Rating: PG-13
Summary: Bucky runs into another super-powered fugitive from justice with a yen for black leather jackets: Skye a.k.a. Daisy Johnson a.k.a. Quake. He figures he's got to have something in common with someone who's got that many names.

This is the last of the fics-for-ACLU donations that have been requested so far, so if you were hoping to get in on that, the deck is cleared! Now is the time! I have raised $465 so far and would really like to make it up to $500. $10 donation minimum! Send me your donation receipt and let the games begin!

I can write for many, many fandoms, including Agents of SHIELD, Captain America, Agent Carter, various American Girl books, various Rosemary Sutcliff books (although if you want one of the more obscure ones, best to check if I've read it), Tortall, many other things for I am a fannish butterfly who flits from flower to flower. Happy to discuss fic specifics with you!
osprey_archer: (Default)
To the illustrious President Snow:

What dictator has time for books? This is the most frequent complaint that we at the SfID hear when we send out our reading list. It’s true that dictatorship leaves little time for leisure - heavy is the head that wears the crown! - but even the busiest dictator needs to carve out some quality alone time for reflection and self-improvement. And what could be a more fruitful topic for reflection than the theory and practice of dictatorship?

One note of caution: don’t read too many memoirs or other works actually written by dictators themselves. Many of them have the obvious drawback of being written by deposed leaders, like Nikita Khrushchev, who are clearly poor role models. But even those written by dictators at the peak of their powers are suspect: they’re writing to burnish their own images, not to give a nitty-gritty how-to guide to other budding dictators. Why help the competition?

Fortunately, however, there are plenty of students of human nature who have provided reams of helpful work. Anything with a title like “cult brainwashing” or “emotional abuse” is likely to be full of wonderful tips. They tend to be couched in terms that suggest that they aim to help their readers foil such strategies, not make use of them, but any clever dictator can figure out how to turn their advice to his own ends.

If, however, you don’t want to suffer through the headache-inducing task of doubling advice back on itself, there’s always C. S. Lewis’s The Screwtape Letters. Told as a series of letters from a demon to his apprentice, a novice in the ways of tempting humans, this book is a must-read for any dictator - for temptation is one of the pillars of any long-running dictatorship. If you want people to work their hearts out for you, then you can’t just give them something to fear; you need to offer them something they want.

Now of course base bribery has its place. The loyal should be rewarded with good food, fancy cars, trips abroad, etc. But Lewis’s chief insight for the dictator is that the strongest and most binding temptation is that of self-righteousness, particularly when it is paired with an ideological commitment to judge oneself not by one’s actions, but by the intended effects of those actions. Minions can forgive themselves any atrocity if they believe they performed it in the name of some far-future utopia - especially if someone in authority tells them so. (Stanley Milgram’s Obedience to Authority is also a key text here. Humans are beautifully receptive to the blandishments of authority figures.)

Solzhenitsyn makes a similar point when he discusses ideology in The Gulag Archipelago, but the SfID realizes that three thousand pages is too much reading to heap on any dictator’s head. The early sections about the secret police, however, are well worth a look. They point out the heartening fact that a totally incompetent secret police force is just as terrifying than a competent one - and perhaps even more so, because the randomness of their arrests fills the populace with superstitious dread.

Hannah Arendt’s Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil is similarly a godsend to any dictator with staffing problems. We can’t count the number of dictators who have come to us despondent over their difficulty in finding good minions. We invariably find that their standards are too high: they want active malice, mustache-twirling, the whole shebang from their rank and file.

But Eichmann in Jerusalem has good news! It turns out that you don’t need any of that. In fact, the best minions are absolutely average types. You want utterly unimaginative nose-to-the-grindstone company man types, the kind who join every organization that comes their way but never lead anything. These people are a dime a dozen. Their consciences may flinch at the first atrocities they’re ordered to carry out, but in most cases their consciences will be too weak to exert any control over their actual behavior - and after the first atrocity is hurdled, habit is a great salve.

In any case, you can turn that flinching of conscience to your own advantage. Focus on your minions’ heroism in overcoming their inner scruples to commit atrocities for the greater good. They still have nightmares about the bloodshed they caused! How heroic they are, overcoming their inner suffering to continue fighting the good fight! Their feelings about their actions are far more important than the actions in themselves.

However, when you’re filling key staffing positions, it’s best to get someone a little more colorful. Stalin liked to hire non-Russians to head his secret police, crescendoing with N. I. Yezhov, a bisexual Jewish dwarf, whose status as a triple outsider made him the perfect scapegoat when Stalin wanted to distance himself from the mass arrests. Find yourself a hunchbacked albino with a foot fetish to place in a highly visible role in your regime. You’ll thank yourself later.

Yours,
The Society for Improved Dictatorship
osprey_archer: (Default)
To the illustrious President Snow:

We can neither confirm nor deny that we became aware of District 13’s existence because President Coin enrolled in our correspondence course. Our student list in confidential, and frankly, we’re embarrassed that you even asked. Surely your District 13 spies can uncover that information for you.

Surely you have spies in District 13? This is Dictatorship 101 stuff, President Snow. We’re growing weary of spelling it out for you.

And speaking of Dictatorship 101, President Snow, your obsession with Katniss Everdeen is complete amateur hour. At least when Stalin obsessed about Trotsky, he was obsessing over an enemy with a proven track record of rallying the masses to revolution and penning scathing denunciations. Katniss, on the other hand, has a proven track record as a poacher. Not very threatening, President Snow.

In fact, you’ve been obsessing about the wrong tribute: Peeta is the real threat. Katniss’s flamboyant gestures may be more eye-catching, but if Peeta hadn’t laid the groundwork for their tale of star-crossed love, she never would have had the chance to show such defiance.

That star-crossed love is the cornerstone of their power, President Snow. Break them up!

Or, at least, make them appear broken up. Given that you have total control of the media and all of their public appearances, that shouldn’t be too difficult.

In our last letter, we suggested framing Gale Hawthorne as a spy, but if you persist in refusing to tell your people about District 13’s existence, there is a much more obvious use for him: he’s Katniss’s illicit pre-Games lover, the man she ran back to the moment she returned to District 13. They’ve been meeting clandestinely in the woods for years! Clearly they’ve been banging for ages. We’re smelling an investigative report right now.

The fact that your news crews earlier portrayed Hawthorne as Katniss’s cousin will only strengthen this smear campaign. There’s no reason to correct this misapprehension. Let your people recoil from those District 12ers and their incestuous ways!

But there’s no reason to stop by linking Katniss with just one lover. No, you’d better portray her as an ungrateful slut who doesn’t give a damn about Peeta, despite all the sacrifices he made for her in the arena. He lost his leg for her! And how is she repaying him? By sleeping with every eligible bachelor in Panem.

It doesn’t matter if she’s actually sleeping with any of them or not. All you need is some photographs of her arm-in-arm with other men and you’re set. At very least, we’re sure that you can maneuver Finnick Odair into a clinch with Katniss: his reputation is so scandalous that all you need is a picture of the two of them standing side by side and a smutty headline and people will assume the worst.

Peeta may be too canny to repudiate Katniss on television, but surely there are Panem gossip rags that could invent an interview. “Peeta Opens Up” - we’re seeing the headline now, preferably accompanied by a photo of Peeta with his head drooping in exhaustion - accompanied by an interview with a sympathetic reporter whose kindly listening at last gives him the chance to share his grief and pain over Katniss’s defection.

If you’re lucky - and canny enough yourself to keep the supposed lovebirds apart - you’ll get a real interview from Katniss in return. And then perhaps a response from Peeta! Dueling interviews across the issues of Panem’s premier gossip magazine! It will make them both look petty and malicious and altogether unsuitable as symbols for a rebellion.

Peeta is the real prize here, President Snow. Your obsession with Katniss has blinded you to the fact that he’s the real mastermind behind their star-crossed lovers act. He’s the one who needs to be neutralized. Could you hook him up with Johanna Mason? Or how about linking him to FInnick Odair too? How do people in Panem feel about homosexuality? We’re guessing a gay scandal will blow Peeta out of the water. If nothing else, it will suggest that his feelings for Katniss are nothing more than an angle.

And that, President Snow, is the killing stroke. Peeta is the one carrying this star-crossed lovers story; if you want to kill it, you need to convince people that he made it all up from the start to manipulate the audience. Hell hath no fury like a populace deceived by someone they consider beneath them.

Yours,
The Society for Improved Dictatorship
osprey_archer: (Default)
To the illustrious President Snow:

It is with some pain that we find ourselves forced to broach this topic. We had hoped that as the course continued you would realize the necessity of coming clean to us, but alas, we have reached the point where we can prevaricate no longer, and still you have not confessed, so we are forced to say: we know that you lied to us about District 13.

We confess ourselves baffled, President Snow. Not baffled that you lied to us - any good dictator lies - but baffled that you told this particular lie, not only to us, but to your people as well. District 13 could be so very useful to you, President Snow!

Oh, sure, we know you think they’re useful to you now - a warning to your other districts what will happen if they rebel. Nuked out of existence, like District 13! But this is simply one more example of your wrong-headed attitude toward fear. You subscribe - forgive us for our bluntness - to the one-dimensional cod-Machiavellian belief that it is better to be feared than loved.

Well, maybe. But what’s best of all, President Snow, is for your subjects to love and fear you in equal measure, as if you were an overbearing father who nonetheless occasionally doles out a few crumbs of love. They may cower from you when they’ve done something wrong, but when there are enemies at the gate, nonetheless they’ll run to you for protection.

But to protect your people from outside enemies, you need to have some outside enemies in the first place, and District 13 seems to be your only option. But what an option it is! District 13 is a truly top-notch enemy, President Snow, exactly the kind of rival we would have designed for you if someone had given us the chance.

They are weaker than you - always a plus in an enemy - but nonetheless truly terrifying because of their nuclear capacity. Simply mentioning the threats of nuclear annihilation they have leveled against Panem ought to be enough to bring your terrified subjects in line.

We realize these threats are the reason why you haven’t told your people of District 13’s existence, but frankly, those threats are clearly a bluff and we’re embarrassed that you haven’t had the guts to call it. District 13 is small, resource-poor, and all in all much more easily wiped off the map than sprawling Panem. It is not going to risk its own annihilation just because you tell your people of its continued existence.

And they make such a delightful contrast to Panem! No need to exaggerate imaginary differences between your two nations: District 13’s militarized, highly mechanized society could hardly be a greater contrast to free-wheeling, fun-loving, Games-running Panem. They’re Sparta to Panem’s Athens - and a starving Sparta at that. They’re stodgy gray East Berlin to Panem’s decadent West. We bet some of them are just dying to defect.

Think of the intelligence coup you’ll score when they do! You just have to make defection a bit easier for them, and step one is simply admitting they exist.

This Cold War metaphor gives us another thought: spies! What better way to keep your people in line than a good spy scare? And it will be especially easy to whip one up because District 13 still has so much in common with the rest of Panem. They look like you, speak like you, could be sneaking among you even as we speak, soaking up information, looking for weak points, pretending to be your friends and neighbors and all the while plotting your destruction.

You might want your spy agency to look into this for real - quietly, of course. Spy scares are good for social control but poor at flushing out actual spies.

And a spy scare would be a wonderful distraction from the tiresome antics of Katniss Everdeen and her supposed lover, that Peeta fellow. Perhaps you could arrange to arrest Katniss’s friend Gale Hawthorne as a spy? He’s certainly spent enough time outside of District 12: everyone’s seen those bags of game he brought back. Little did they know that this was merely a blind to cover for his real purpose out in the wilds: meeting his spymaster from District 13!

At very least, arresting one of Katniss’s friends ought to make her take you seriously. And if you’re lucky, she’ll unwisely try to fight the arrest - not only connecting herself with a known spy, but making herself look unfaithful to Peeta in the process. We have no doubt that the people will turn on her in a heartbeat if she destroys the love story they’ve enjoyed so much.

Yours,
The Society for Improved Dictatorship
osprey_archer: (Default)
To the illustrious President Snow:

We’ve been following Katniss Everdeen’s tour through Panem with interest and concern. Concern because you don’t seem to have followed our advice to present her as a lunatic - did our letter not arrive in time? - but interest, also, because the tour has given us a fascinating view of the political organization of Panem. We hadn’t realized that each district was in charge of one industry or that the districts had so little contact with each other. What an excellent system for sowing distrust between districts! Pity you haven’t done more with it.

In our last letter, we urged you to try to convince people to blame themselves for their malcontent. This is fine advice as far as it goes, but let’s face it, self-blame only goes so far. Few people are such delusional depressives that they can blame themselves for all their ills when not only they but everyone else they know is slowly succumbing to malnutrition despite working twelve hour days. They need an outside force to blame, and the Victory Tour has made it clear that they’ve picked you.

This is unfortunate, but never fear! All is not lost. You simply need to provide them with a new target at which to direct their blame, and the district system provides an excellent opportunity. You simply need to convince your subjects to direct their fear and anger and hatred at people in the other districts, rather than the Capitol.

Admittedly, you face an uphill battle. Currently, the residents of the districts seem to feel a deplorable level of empathy toward each other. They may hate the districts that field Career tributes to the Hunger Games, but their hearts clearly bleed for the families in non-Career districts who have had their children torn away from them by this bloody spectacle.

But there’s an easy fix, President Snow. All your tributes need to become Careers.

Once the tributes are no longer innocents but highly trained warriors who chose this life for personal advancement, their suffering will cease to bridge chasms between districts. Instead, each district will loathe the tributes of all other districts, and through that loathing, learn to loathe the other districts as well. You simply need to reframe the Games so that your people see them not as a punishment, but as their one and only providential chance for their children to escape this life of drudgery.

You shouldn’t have to pick the tributes by lottery. Parents should be lining up to send their children to the Games! Every district ought to follow Districts 1, 2, and 4 in having a tribute training program. You’re already spending money on schools - a sterling example of your general benevolence, by the way. Perhaps a little too much benevolence? Literacy only stirs up trouble.

But, as you’ve already set up the schools, you might as well spend just a little bit extra so each district can have a training program, too.

Moreover, district training programs offer a beautiful opportunity to expand the bread-and-circuses side of your reign. How should a program pick which of its highly trained students wins the honor of representing their district in the Hunger Games? You’ll need some kind of exam. And what exam could be better than a Hunger Game in miniature?

Of course, the candidates shouldn’t actually kill each other in the Mini Games. Actual killing should be preserved for the Hunger Games proper to give them a special level of excitement. Moreover, these highly trained children are an excellent resource that shouldn’t be wasted. The losers of the Mini Games can be easily drafted as district Peacekeepers.

(As a side note, we hear you’re currently getting all your Peacekeepers from the Capitol. No wonder they’re all a bunch of incompetents; with all the opportunities the Capitol affords, only the very dregs must be signing up to slog their lives away out in the districts. The districts, on the other hand, offer no other method of social advancement, and therefore will send you the cream of their youth.)

Winning the opportunity to be the district tribute through the Mini Games will only enhance the honor and prestige of this position.

Not only will the Mini Games enhance the honor of being chosen as tribute, but they will provide an important lesser holiday during the slow season between Hunger Games. (Initial selection for the training program may provide another such occasion.)

Moreover, the Mini Games will offer a golden opportunity to carve deep community rifts. Encourage betting. Stoke up the animosity between different segments of the community as they root for their own candidates. With luck, some of these rivalries will last for decades after the chosen tribute went off and died in the Games proper. Such petty grudges provide people a safe outlet for anger they might otherwise direct at the Capitol.

When parents start fighting each other to place their children in the training program, willing to risk their children’s lives for the slim hope that their children might better their social status - well, when that moment comes, you can rest secure in the strength of your system. There are few chains as strong as hope.

Once your districts take proper pride in their own tributes, then a commensurate loathing of other districts’ tributes – and with it, the other districts themselves – will naturally follow. When they hear of suffering in another district, their response will not be sympathy, but contempt and pleasure: this misfortune will only make it easier for their own tribute to triumph in the next Games.

Moreover, true animosity between districts can only make future Hunger Games more exciting. If there’s a food shortage, say, nothing would be more natural than a few jocular comments from Caesar Flickerman about appropriate ways to dispatch the District 11 tributes in punishment for their district’s crimes. Disemboweling seems like an appropriate response, don’t you think?

Yours,
The Society for Improved Dictatorship

***

Next week's installment is currently entitled "Do You Want to Build an Empire?" but the focus has changed somewhat from purely empire to relations with outside powers in general, so I may have to come up with a new title.

And that will be the last week, although I have a few ideas for supplementary materials, if anyone donates $10+ to the ACLU. Possibilities include:

Food as a Tool for Empire
The Smart Dictator's Reading List
Sex and the Single Dictator (President Snow isn't married, is he? I guess that's a strike against the idea that the Presidency of Panem might be heritable: you'd think he'd be a bit more concerned about providing an heir.)

And, for something a bit different, an article/advertisement for the course, presumably published in Dictators Today. Possibly with testimonials for other dictators, fictional and factual.
osprey_archer: (Default)
To the illustrious President Snow:

Thank you for laying out your Katniss Everdeen problem for us in your last letter. Annoying though she sounds, we see no reason for alarm; her upcoming appearances on her Hunger Games victory tour should give you ample opportunity to discredit her. Simply convince the populace that she’s tragically insane, and they may very well realize that their rebellious rumblings are unhinged as well without any more effort on your part.

Given her family history, it might be tempting to present her illness as depression, but we advise against it. Depression has some unfortunate positive folkloric connotations among the uneducated masses: artistic talent, deep emotional sensitivity, even leadership qualities, if they’ve spent too much time imbibing Abraham Lincoln biographies. At very least, the people may latch on to the idea that “She’s miserable, and we are too,” which will only strengthen their sense of identification with her.

No, if you’re going to discredit her, you’d better fake a full psychotic break. Start a whisper campaign: the girl sees things, she’s got voices in her head. For extra verisimilitude, pretend to try to stamp out the rumors: that will make them spread like wildfire.

Then all you’ll need from Miss Everdeen is bizarre behavior at a couple of public appearances, and that can be induced easily enough with drugs. Perhaps she could claw Claudius Templesmith’s face on live television? She’s got an impulsive streak that can be easily turned to your advantage here.

Oh, but for maximum impact, it ought to be Peeta’s face that she claws on camera. Think what a beautiful addition this would be to their love story! The saintly Peeta, his cheek still bleeding from her attack, cradles a weeping Katniss in his arms as she sobs out disjointed words that only make her insanity tragically obvious. Oh, we’re wiping away a tear just imagining the propaganda coup. There won’t be a dry eye in Panem when you broadcast it.

This will solve your current problem. But this is only the beginning of what greater mental health awareness can do for your reign! We urge you to commit to an extensive effort to educate your people about the dangers of Rebellious Emotive Disorder (RED). This disease has been recognized as far back as antiquity. In the antebellum American south, where RED was recognized under the name drapetomania, they considered the sovereign treatment whipping and hard labor. It wasn’t until Soviet times that RED came under the proper care of psychiatry.

Sufferers may exhibit sullenness, lethargy, a distrust of authority, an aversion to work (often coupled with the fatalistic belief that hard work will not improve their lot in life), and dissatisfaction with the current state of society. Their hallmark delusion is that it is society’s flaws, not their own defective brain chemistry, that causes their unhappiness. People who suffer from RED later in life often display a tendency toward the disorder even in early childhood, when they are drawn to legends about “heroic” outlaws and pirates. Robin Hood is an oft-mentioned favorite.

As the disease grows more severe, sufferers begin to experience suicide ideation, particularly in the form of a suicidal desire to fight the government. They may believe that going out dramatically in their paranoid fight against the government would be preferable to living a quiet, orderly life.

In the most severe cases, sufferers act on their impulses. Because RED is highly contagious, this can result not merely in lone suicidal terrorist attacks, but full-scale rebellion.

RED requires prompt and extensive treatment if there is to be any hope for remission. Although some sufferers prove incurable and must be kept in permanent quarantine, many can be treated successfully and sent back to their districts to live useful lives if their illness is identified soon enough. All your subjects should be encouraged to help their friends and loved ones by telling a trusted authority figure as soon as soon as they notice signs of RED.

Ideally, however, this kindly intervention should prove unnecessary. Once mental health awareness has really taken root, your patients will start presenting themselves for treatment as soon as they recognize symptoms of their own mental disintegration. It is so much easier to help patients who already accept their own insanity: they are far more amenable to replacing their bad thoughts (“I’m unhappy because society is so unfair; only revolution can make me happy”) with good ones (“I’m unhappy because my brain chemistry is broken; I know this must be true because only a person with a defective brain could be unhappy in a society as wonderful as the one I live in. Only submitting completely to treatment will make me happy”).

But resistance is the hallmark symptom of RED, and therefore most patients do prove resistant to treatment. The infectious nature of the disease often proves the practitioners’ friend in this regard: once RED patients fully understand that their loved ones may be infected, which would force the authorities to bring them in for treatment as well, they often become much more cooperative. The power of love is truly impressive.

However, for a serious mental health disorder like RED, one can’t depend on love alone for the solution. We urge you to consider transporting the most severe RED cases to the Capitol so they can receive top of the line treatment. The mere glimpse of the Capitol’s wealth, splendor, and vast, glittering military parades is often enough to lift the clouds of rebellion from all but the sickest of sufferers. It may be tempting to terminate treatment then, but it’s important to continue treatment to completion. Early termination often leads to relapse.

There will doubtless be some grumbling among your subjects that the regimen used to combat this disease turns patients into zombies, even heightens the risk of suicide. This is simply a sign that your subjects are deeply prejudiced against mental illness and would prefer for their mentally ill brethren to suffer indefinitely rather than receive the help they need. More education should set them straight. If it does not, their persistent grumblings may very well indicate that they themselves suffer from RED, and deserve prompt, compassionate, and comprehensive treatment.

Besides, suicide (as distinct from suicidal terrorist attacks) is far from the worst outcome in cases of RED. Better dead than RED, as they say.

And that’s another way to deal with the Katniss Everdeen problem, if worst comes to worst. If she won’t commit suicide for you, once you’ve set up convincing evidence of her instability, you can always fake it. Perhaps a double suicide with Peeta, even? He finds her dead body and kills himself in despair. There’s nothing more romantic than the excesses of young love.

Your friends,
The Society for Improved Dictatorship
osprey_archer: (Default)
To the illustrious President Snow:

Many thanks for the cake replica of the Capitol that you sent us. It’s rare for a cake to be as delicious as it is beautiful - a repulsive layer of fondant often seems to be the price for elegance - but your chef exquisitely balanced the demands of the tongue and the eye. Please relay our compliments.

We’re especially glad to have received this token of your esteem because we know our next lesson is going to be hard to swallow. And that masticatory metaphor is intentional, President Snow, because if we had to pick one thing that worries us about your reign, it’s the food situation.

We know that in our last epistle we told you to focus on abstract concepts. But frankly, President Snow, we didn’t mean you. You should keep your people stuffed full of nonsense about freedom and glory, but you yourself need to keep your eyes always on nitty-gritty reality, and the nitty-gritty reality is that starving people are hopeless people - and therefore free people, people who have lost everything and are ripe for rebellion.

You’ve surely heard the phrase “bread and circuses”? You’ve got the circuses part down, but there’s a reason the bread is listed first. It’s hard to focus on even the most spectacular bloodbath at the circus when your stomach is so empty that it’s trying to eat your spleen.

Well-fed philosophers don’t spark revolts. It’s hardly even worth repressing them; that only brings attention to their work. No, it’s hungry women in bread lines that you need to watch out for, President Snow. Heed the examples of King Louis XVI and Tsar Nicholas II. No dictator can be called successful who ends up executed by his own subjects.

It’s not a bad idea to have a pair of listening ears at every bakery. Shoppers love to indulge a good grumble, and a good listener can become an invaluable barometer of social mood. When the mumbles turn to shouts, that’s a sign that the women have had enough, and you’re done for if you don’t ship in some bread pronto.

We suspect that you’ve kept your subjects hungry on the grounds that a hungry populace will be too tired and busy scouting for food to even think about revolt. This is true as far as it goes. But when the people get too hungry - when they reach the grim conclusion that there is nothing left but to watch their children starve to death - they’ll skip right over thinking about revolt to doing it.

By no means do we think that you should utterly reverse your policy and begin providing plentiful food year round. Keep the populace hungry. But don’t push them to the point of starvation. Ensure that even in their hungriest moments they always have a feast to look forward to - a feast that is, of course, provided by the bounteous generosity of the Capitol.

You know what would make the Hunger Games even better? Feasts. After seventy-five years it’s probably too late to rename the Hunger Games, but you can certainly change the associations people have with the name. No more mandatory standing in the village square, stomachs growling, staring sullenly at the screen. No! Now when people think of the Games, they’ll think of the one good time of the year when they aren’t hungry.

(We also strongly suggesting cultivating special seasonal Hunger Games dishes. For more information, please consider purchasing our expansion pack, Food as an Aid to Empire. Remember, There’s No Price Too Great for a Great Dictatorship! (™))

A supplementary feast when the victorious tribute visits each district may also be in order. An entire year between feasts is too taxing for both the human memory and the human stomach.

Here’s some next-level dictatorship for you: never mandate if you can make people do something of their own supposedly free will. Lay out vast feasts at the screenings of the Hunger Games, and the people will flock to watch. Their hungry children with demand it.

True, the viewers will be too busy chewing to notice some of the finer points of the games, but they’ll still get the highlights. Get them relaxed, let them drink a little beer (maybe a lot of beer), and their natural human propensity to root for their own and loathe their enemies will come out. Entice the people in with cakes and ale, and they won’t just be sullen bodies wishing they were somewhere else as they try not to watch the show. They’ll get engaged. They’ll get invested. They’ll become complicit.

Soon they’ll love the Games just as much as the denizens of the Capitol do - and for a far lower price tag, to boot. By all means, President Snow, let them eat cake.

Your replete friends,
The Society for Improved Dictatorship
osprey_archer: (kitty)
To the soon-to-be-ex President Snow:

We wash our hands of you. Had you heeded our advice in our last urgent letter, your reign might yet have been saved, but instead you stubbornly continued down your wrong-headed path. Everything you’ve ever built is about to tumble down around you and we want you to know that it is 100% your fault.

The faults in your governing style are too manifold for us to enumerate them all in a single epistle, but in the end, they can all be boiled down to two words: Katniss Everdeen.

Spoilers for Catching Fire )

We are ashamed that we allowed you to purchase our course. Your name is a blot on our list of alumni.

The Society for Improved Dictatorship

Profile

osprey_archer: (Default)
osprey_archer

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    123
4 5 6 7 8910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated May. 13th, 2025 06:42 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios