Fandom Meme 29
Aug. 14th, 2021 07:26 am29. Have you ever tried to write for a fandom or ship, and found you couldn’t?
I tried valiantly to write Pushing Daisies fic - in fact, I even posted some, in the dubious hope that it was better than I thought it was - but really it never came together. The show had such a specific visual and audio aesthetic which was central to the whole experience, and I found it basically impossible to translate into the written word.
As I recall, a lot of other fanfic writers had this problem too. I think this was the first show where I really grasped that just because you loved a show (or any other piece of media), that didn’t mean that you would love the fic. In this case it wasn’t even a clash in shipping priorities - I loved Ned/Chuck, which was the big ship. The fic just didn’t scratch the same itch as the show and it didn’t seem to scratch any other itches, either.
I’ve also never been able to write sitcom fic. It’s partly the rapid one-liners (honestly, I have so much admiration for people who can write that, either in a TV show or in fic) and partly the sort of absurdist logic that many sitcoms employ. The characters’ actions seem perfectly natural when the actors on screen are doing it, but when I sit down and try to write a fic about them, everything just seems to fall apart in my hands somehow.
I tried valiantly to write Pushing Daisies fic - in fact, I even posted some, in the dubious hope that it was better than I thought it was - but really it never came together. The show had such a specific visual and audio aesthetic which was central to the whole experience, and I found it basically impossible to translate into the written word.
As I recall, a lot of other fanfic writers had this problem too. I think this was the first show where I really grasped that just because you loved a show (or any other piece of media), that didn’t mean that you would love the fic. In this case it wasn’t even a clash in shipping priorities - I loved Ned/Chuck, which was the big ship. The fic just didn’t scratch the same itch as the show and it didn’t seem to scratch any other itches, either.
I’ve also never been able to write sitcom fic. It’s partly the rapid one-liners (honestly, I have so much admiration for people who can write that, either in a TV show or in fic) and partly the sort of absurdist logic that many sitcoms employ. The characters’ actions seem perfectly natural when the actors on screen are doing it, but when I sit down and try to write a fic about them, everything just seems to fall apart in my hands somehow.