osprey_archer: (Default)
I’ve been copying out my old book lists, and as I have been copying I have been reminded of a number of authors whose work I meant to explore further and ongoing series that may have had new installments since I last read them.

One of these series was Fence, the graphic novel series about the super cute boys on the King’s Row fencing team, which has had TWO new volumes since I last read it. The local library only had the first of these two, so I got that and read it… and then went back to the library and got the first four volumes to reread them… and then at last got the sixth volume from a different library, and of course had to reread the fifth book before I read the sixth, since the fifth and sixth volume are both about the King’s Row trip to fencing camp! And also why turn down any excuse to read a bit more Fence?

It was interesting coming back to the graphic novels after reading Sarah Rees Brennan’s Fence novelizations, which were delightful but light on actual fencing. Fence the comic has plenty of cute shippy moments, but there are also a lot of fencing sequences, perhaps in part because it’s easier to make a fencing match intelligible to a largely non-fencing audience if there are pictures to show what’s going on.

Some of the fencing sequences double as cute shippy moments, like the bit at the end of volume four where Seiji, exasperated by Nicholas’s poor technique, decides to train him, which of course means standing behind him and guiding his motions like the pottery scene in Ghost. And some of them are not shippy but feature great character development, like the time that Aidan manages to beat Seiji by throwing him off his game with trash talk.

This has given me the theory that Jesse Coste, Seiji’s former BFF (and perhaps more…), defeated Seiji at World’s through a similar method, possibly throwing him off his game by saying that their relationship was not as important to him as it was to Seiji. Whatever happened, Seiji was so upset afterward that he left the next day to fence in France for a year. He’s still so deranged about Jesse Coste that when the coach mentions Jesse’s team is going to stop by fencing camp, Seiji actually drops his epee.

There’s a hilarious bit in volume six where another fencer mentions to Nicholas that Seiji and Jesse Cost were perhaps “more than friends,” and Nicholas (who is very smart in his own way but also the stupidest person in the world) says, “Right! They’re rivals!”

Which says a lot about Nicholas consistently casting himself as Seiji’s rival. But then in volume 6, when Nicholas barges into a conversation between Seiji and Jesse Coste, Seiji introduces Nicholas as “my friend,” at which point Nicholas practically gets hearteyes… so maybe friends are better than rivals after all!

At the rate that Fence is publishing we will perhaps have answers to some of these questions by 2040 or so. On the one hand, I want more! Tell me what happens! But on the other hand, I’ve reached a time in my life where I truly appreciate things that come out more slowly, just because there’s so much that it’s hard to keep up.
osprey_archer: (books)
I enjoyed Sarah Rees Brennan’s Fence: Disarmed, but I did not find it as deliciously delightful as her earlier Fence novel, Fence: Striking Distance. This is too bad, because it has a lot of parts that I liked! These included:

- Eugene Labao, Token Straight Dude, having a romance with a French girl at Special European Fencing camp. (They eventually break up because “there’s a time in a girl’s life when she has to devote herself to the blade.”)

- the assistant coach has SUCH a crush on the head coach, because why not, Brennan saw the chance to throw that in and she went for it!

- early in the book, when Seiji realizes Nicholas can’t afford Special European Fencing Camp, he calls his dad to talk about paying Nicholas’s way for him. When Seiji brings up Nicholas, Seiji’s dad is clearly Gearing Up to be Supportive when Seiji comes out, and then Seiji is like, “Oh, we should talk about Eugene too,” and his dad is like “Eugene… too…?” and Seiji is all, “Actually, the whole fencing team!” and his dad is like “!!!!!!” … and then FINALLY realizes that Seiji is actually calling in hopes that his dad will finance the fencing team’s trip. Oh my God, Seiji’s dad!

- Bobby’s roommate Dante (who is super in love with Dante and super not interested in fencing) comes along to fencing camp just to be with Bobby… and also to visit his relatives who live just over the border in Italy, at which point Bobby begins to pine for Dante’s presence (without apparently seeing that pining in a romantic light, as Bobby remains enamored of Seiji). The role reversal just got me.

In general, the complicated relationship dynamics of this book just got me. So good!

The one thing that did not get me is, sadly, also the A plot: Aiden/Harvard. Fence: Disarmed leans even harder into the “Aiden is an asshole who uses and discards boys like Dixie cups” characterization, and as it turns out Fence: Striking Distance was already at the upper limit of my tolerance for this sort of thing.

I get that “My beloved is a jerk to EVERYONE BUT ME” is a fantasy that appeals to many people. (I personally do not see it, but as rereading the Queen’s Thief books has reminded me, I ship maimed thief/the woman who maimed him, and people who live in glass houses etc etc.) However, in this book Aiden is mean to everyone AND ALSO Harvard, so by the time they get together I was like “…are you sure you really want him, Harvard? I mean clearly you do but do you REALLY?”

…I’m also really curious how/if the Fence graphic novels will deal with the fact that Aiden & Harvard got together in a spinoff novel. Do the spinoffs count as canonical, or will the graphic novels simply ignore them? We shall see!
osprey_archer: (Default)
What I’ve Just Finished Reading

Aiden halted by the first cute boy he saw. “What are you doing tonight?”

The boy seemed staggered. Harvard didn’t blame him. Aiden sounded rather as though he was demanding the boy’s money or his life.

“Being… heterosexual?” the boy answered at last.

Aiden stood there being gorgeous at him. A stunned and dazzled expression grew on the boy’s face, as though he’d accidentally looked directly into the sun or encountered a pinup model.

“Or maybe…not?” said the boy, a long pause between the words.


Sarah Rees Brennan’s Fence: Striking Distance is an absolute delight that frequently had me laughing and/or shrieking out loud. I went into this book wanting to smack Aiden and by the end of the book… well, okay, I still wanted to smack Aiden, but in a kind and loving way.

I loved Brennan’s characterization of Aiden and Harvard, and I thought Nicholas was pretty good (LOVED the way that his attention just slides of Aiden whenever Aiden talks; I always enjoy a character who is just not charmed by the Most Charming character), but I had some doubts about her characterization of Seiji. She presents him as just Not Getting social cues, whereas in the graphic novels I much more had the impression that he could have gotten social cues if he gave a damn, which he doesn’t.

I also loved Nancy Farmer’s A Girl Named Disaster, although I felt it very slightly fell off at the end, which seems to be almost unavoidable in the wilderness adventure genre; inevitably the character must return to civilization and I always feel like, “But do they HAVE to?” And, well, Nhamo was on the verge of starvation, so clearly she did.

The wilderness adventure parts are great, though, and they make up the bulk of the book. And it’s by no means a bad ending! Just not as exciting as Nhamo in the wilderness talking to a maybe-ghost (or maybe-dream) about how to repair her boat.

What I’m Reading Now

[personal profile] asakiyume! I bet Nancy Farmer’s The Ear, the Eye, and the Arm was the book you were thinking of last week with the walled village where people dress in traditional style, because that is ABSOLUTELY something that happens in this book! Outside is a futuristic city with flying buses and an old dump that has become a plastic mine; within the walls, a traditional village where people tell riddles to pass the time.

I’ve also been galloping through Bessel van der Kolk’s The Body Keeps the Score: Brain, Mind, and Body in the Healing of Trauma, you know, for a little light reading (but also research for the amount of trauma that I keep dumping on the heads of the poor benighted characters in my books, who really deserved better from life).

What I Plan to Read Next

I would like to read Fence: Disarmed, but ALAS, the library doesn’t have it yet, so I will have to make do with Sarah Rees Brennan’s earlier novel In Other Lands for now. I’ve meant to read it for ages anyway.
osprey_archer: (books)
What I’ve Just Finished Reading

Despite my quibbles last week, I enjoyed Emma Southon’s A Fatal Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum: Murder in Ancient Rome so much that I instantly went on to her earlier book Agrippina: The Most Extraordinary Woman of the Roman World. Despite that perhaps rather bombastic subtitle, I enjoyed it even more.

I especially appreciated the way that the book unpacks the primary sources. Southon points out that all the extant sources were written decades or centuries after Agrippina’s death (so they’re not really primary sources at all - you wouldn’t call something written today a primary source about Watergate) and also often lays the different accounts side by side so you can see how they differ, and it’s really interesting to see how divergent the different histories often are - and also it feels very telling on the few occasions they all converge on a single story, like Agrippina’s assassination of Claudius.

(This is an interesting moment because Southon doesn’t really want Agrippina to have assassinated her uncle/husband Claudius, as it seems to contradict the picture she’s built up of Agrippina, Able Administrator, Not as Murdery as She’s Painted. However, the rare moment of agreement between all the sources forces her to say, okay, Agrippina probably did it.)

Vladimir Gilyarovsky’s Moscow and Muscovites, however, remained a struggle all the way through. Maybe it really lost something in translation? It’s disappointing because I had really looked forward to this book, but such is life.

I also zoomed through volumes one to four of Fence, which is delightful, and you will be UNSURPRISED to learn that Ice Prince Seiji has stolen my heart. But it’s also frustrating, because the first four volumes are really just the beginning of the story, the set-up, and it’s not at all clear when the next graphic novel will come out!

There are two tie-in novels by Sarah Rees Brennan, which of course I will read, but I’m not sure if these are direct continuations of the story (as in, you read the first four graphic novels, then you read the two tie-in novels, then you read the next graphic novel whenever it comes out…) or are more along the lines of optional extras.

What I’m Reading Now

I found Nancy Farmer's House of the Scorpion a grim slog, and expected to have the same reaction to A Girl Named Disaster, but actually it’s great! Strong My Side of the Mountain “child surviving in the wilderness” vibes, except instead of a boy in the Catskills it’s about a girl on the border between Mozambique and Zimbabwe. Right now she’s sort of accidentally started observing a baboon troop and I’m eating it up with a spoon.

What I Plan to Read Next

Nancy Farmer's The Ear, the Eye, and the Arm. A Girl Named Disaster has made me much more hopeful about this book!

Profile

osprey_archer: (Default)
osprey_archer

June 2025

S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4 5 67
8 910 11 121314
15 161718192021
22232425262728
2930     

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 16th, 2025 08:41 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios