a girl wishes that a traveling salesman would “put down roots,” which ends up turning him into a tree, when what she really wants is for him to fall in love with her - why wouldn’t she just wish for that?
She was sufficiently dim and naive that she thought he was in love with her, just ever-so-slightly more in love with the road.
Also, I think it's a key of the wish-giving genre that people in these stories have never once heard a story in which wishes go wrong, or else they would have planned out their wishes better. IRL, I like to imagine most of us, like the protagonist of Time at the Top, have already planned out our three wishes to provide maximum benefit with a minimum of risk. (Alas for her, she didn't get three wishes! She got three trips into the past. It works out well enough anyway.)
no subject
She was sufficiently dim and naive that she thought he was in love with her, just ever-so-slightly more in love with the road.
Also, I think it's a key of the wish-giving genre that people in these stories have never once heard a story in which wishes go wrong, or else they would have planned out their wishes better. IRL, I like to imagine most of us, like the protagonist of Time at the Top, have already planned out our three wishes to provide maximum benefit with a minimum of risk. (Alas for her, she didn't get three wishes! She got three trips into the past. It works out well enough anyway.)